A Closer Look: Design and Key Features
The Smith & Wesson Model 19 Carry Comp. The name itself evokes a sense of rugged elegance, a blend of classic revolver design and modern enhancements tailored for concealed carry. It promises a powerful punch in a relatively compact package, appealing to both seasoned shooters and those looking for a reliable self-defense firearm. But beneath the sleek exterior and promises of performance lies a truth every potential owner needs to understand: the Model 19 Carry Comp, while undoubtedly a fine handgun, isn’t without its quirks. This article will delve into the common issues encountered by owners, offering insights and advice to help you make an informed decision or better maintain your trusted sidearm. While the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp offers many advantages for concealed carry, potential owners should be aware of certain issues that can impact reliability and performance.
This particular model, a variation on the legendary Model 19, attempts to blend the advantages of the classic K-frame revolver with the demands of modern concealed carry. Let’s explore why it’s a favorite and what potential problems you might encounter.
Design and Key Features
The S&W Model 19 Carry Comp draws heavily from its predecessor, the Model 19, a revolver lauded for its balance of size, power, and shootability. This Carry Comp variation typically features a shorter barrel length, usually around three inches. This shorter barrel, coupled with a concealed hammer design, makes it more manageable for concealed carry, allowing the user to carry with less print or bulk.
The “Carry Comp” moniker highlights the most distinguishing feature of this model: a compensator, usually incorporated into the barrel design. The primary purpose of the porting is to redirect propellant gasses upwards, thereby reducing felt recoil and muzzle climb. This is a significant benefit in rapid-fire scenarios, allowing for faster follow-up shots.
Beyond the porting, these revolvers often boast other features that enhance their usability. Ergonomic grips designed for comfortable handling and control, and improved sight systems, typically a high-visibility front sight paired with an adjustable or fixed rear sight are usually present. The goal is simple: to make the Model 19 easier to control and more accurate, particularly in the high-stress environment of self-defense. The trigger is also a critical element. A smooth and consistent trigger pull is crucial for accurate shooting.
The intent is clear: to create a powerful, easily concealed, and accurate revolver specifically designed for those who prioritize personal protection.
Navigating the Terrain: Common Challenges
While the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp offers numerous advantages, potential owners must be aware of certain problems that can crop up.
Recoil and Porting Dynamics
While the porting on the Carry Comp aims to reduce recoil, it does so in a way that introduces other factors to consider.
One of the first things new owners notice is the muzzle flash. The diverted gasses, especially when firing at low light conditions, can produce a bright flash, which can temporarily obscure the shooter’s vision. While not always a deal breaker, it’s something to consider for those who anticipate needing to use their firearm in reduced-light situations.
The porting itself can also present challenges. Carbon buildup from the burning propellant can accumulate within the ports. This accumulation, if left unaddressed, can affect the effectiveness of the compensator and might influence the overall performance. Careful and thorough cleaning, especially around the porting area, becomes essential to maintain the revolver’s efficiency.
Consider also the type of ammunition you plan to use. Certain loads, particularly those with slower-burning propellants, might produce more flash. It is important to determine the type of ammo the gun is most efficient with.
The Trigger’s Tale
The trigger mechanism is the heart of any revolver’s performance. A smooth, predictable trigger pull is essential for accurate shot placement. Some Model 19 Carry Comp owners have reported experiencing variations in trigger pull quality. This may manifest as grittiness, a heavy trigger pull, or inconsistencies in the trigger’s break.
Fortunately, there are solutions. Some owners may benefit from professional trigger work. This could involve polishing internal components, adjusting spring weights, or other modifications to improve the feel of the trigger pull. Regular cleaning and lubrication of the trigger mechanism can also help to maintain smooth operation.
The Quest for Reliability
Reliability is paramount in any firearm, especially one intended for self-defense. Unfortunately, a few reliability issues have been reported with the Model 19 Carry Comp.
Extraction and ejection problems can sometimes arise. This can be caused by issues with the cartridge cases, the cylinder’s timing, or other factors. The cylinder’s timing, the precise alignment of the cylinder with the barrel during firing, must be perfect. Issues here can lead to malfunctions.
Carbon buildup from the porting can also contribute to reliability problems. If the ports are not properly cleaned, carbon deposits can accumulate and potentially interfere with the operation of the cylinder or ejector.
Regular cleaning and maintenance are critical. This includes thoroughly cleaning the cylinder chambers, the forcing cone, and the ejector rod. Using high-quality lubricants can also help to minimize friction and ensure smooth operation.
Magazines (if applicable) can sometimes present their own set of issues. Ensure that you are using high-quality magazines, that they are properly maintained, and that they are compatible with the model.
Finish and Durability
The finish on a firearm plays a crucial role in protecting it from the elements and preventing wear and tear. The Model 19 Carry Comp often has a finish that is intended to withstand the rigors of daily carry. However, the finish can still be susceptible to wear.
Regular cleaning and proper lubrication are essential. It is important to use a high-quality gun oil to protect the metal components from corrosion and rust. Holster selection is a key factor in preventing finish wear. The constant friction from drawing and re-holstering the gun can wear down the finish over time. If possible, choose a holster made from materials that are less abrasive, such as leather or a material that won’t scrape the finish off of the firearm.
The Ammunition Equation
The ammunition you choose plays a pivotal role in your Carry Comp’s performance and reliability.
It is best to understand the type of ammo the gun is most efficient with, and test several different types. This can involve everything from weight and type. Testing is critical.
A Maintenance Mindset: Keeping Your Carry Comp Running
Regular maintenance is vital to maintaining the reliability and performance of your S&W Model 19 Carry Comp.
A comprehensive cleaning regimen should be established. You should remove carbon buildup from the forcing cone, the chambers, and the porting. This will ensure it runs properly. The use of the correct cleaning solvents and lubricants is important.
Regular lubrication is key. Use a high-quality gun oil to keep internal components lubricated and prevent rust.
A holster that fits properly is a necessity. This will protect the finish and ensure that the firearm is stored safely.
Making the Decision: Considerations for Buyers
Before purchasing a S&W Model 19 Carry Comp, it is crucial to weigh the advantages and disadvantages. It offers a powerful and compact platform for concealed carry. It may have a few potential issues that need to be considered.
One potential concern is the felt recoil of the firearm. This will depend on the type of ammunition used and the shooter’s experience.
Another factor is the trigger pull quality. Potential buyers should carefully assess the trigger pull and decide whether it meets their personal preferences.
Overall, the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp is a solid choice for concealed carry. However, it is important to be aware of the potential problems, understand how to address them, and determine if it fits your needs.
In Conclusion: A Balanced Assessment
The S&W Model 19 Carry Comp is, undeniably, a compelling handgun. Its combination of power, size, and features makes it a favorite of many, and a good choice for concealed carry. Yet, it’s crucial to acknowledge the potential challenges. Issues with muzzle flash, carbon buildup, trigger quality, and finish wear are possible.
The best thing an owner can do is clean, maintain, and test it frequently.
Always remember to prioritize safe handling practices. By understanding the potential issues, choosing the right ammunition, and committing to regular maintenance, you can maximize your Model 19 Carry Comp’s performance and ensure it is ready to perform when you need it most.
